Copyright (c) 1995 University of Michigan Law School
Michigan Journal of International Law
ARTICLE: THE CONCEPT OF HUMANITARIAN INTERVENTION REVISITED *
* Provost, Jawaharlal Nehru University, New Delhi, India.
16 Mich. J. Int'l L. 883
Yogesh K. Tyagi **
Every case of humanitarian intervention gives rise to mixed feelings of hope and despair. Hope comes from the involvement of the international community, and despair comes from the fact that the state system is still too weak to meet its basic responsibility, namely, the protection of human dignity. Influenced by these mixed feelings, the present article attempts a new look at the concept of humanitarian intervention. In Part I, it examines the concept of humanitarian intervention. Part II analyzes the principal aspects of humanitarian intervention: the reasons for the intervention, the character of the target state, and the status of the intervenor. In Part III, the article examines the major issues involved in these interventions, particularly their objectives, validity, nature, and priority. This exercise exposes some striking inadequacies in the existing law relating to humanitarian intervention. An understanding and appreciation of these inadequacies would help in the evolution of a new international humanitarian order, the salient features of which are discussed in Part IV of the article.
I. The Concept
Humanitarian intervention is a fragile alliance of two different concepts: human rights and intervention. The concept of human rights is highly respectable, whereas the concept of intervention is highly problematic. The law applicable to humanitarian intervention has not only inherited the ambiguities present in both of these concepts, but has also generated ambiguities of its own through century-old, haphazard, and controversial practices of states and non-state entities.
The basis for a humanitarian intervention lies in the absence ...
If you are interested in obtaining a lexis.com® ID and Password, please contact us at 1-(800)-227-4908 or visit us at http://www.lexisnexis.com/.