ARTICLE: WHAT WERE THEY THINKING? FOURTH AMENDMENT UNREASONABLENESS IN ATWATER V. CITY OF LAGO VISTA Skip over navigation
LexisNexis® Browse Law Reviews and Treatises
Skip over navigation
Sign in with your lexis.com® ID to access the full text of this article.
-OR-
Order the full text of this article if you do not have a lexis.com® ID.
 
Price: 
US $22.00 (+ tax)
 
 

Copyright (c) 2002 Fordham Law Review
Fordham Law Review

ARTICLE: WHAT WERE THEY THINKING? FOURTH AMENDMENT UNREASONABLENESS IN ATWATER V. CITY OF LAGO VISTA

November, 2002

71 Fordham L. Rev. 329

Author

Richard S. Frase*

Excerpt



Introduction
 
In Atwater v. City of Lago Vista, 1 a five-to-four majority of the Supreme Court held that the Fourth Amendment places no limitations other than probable cause on police discretion to make a custodial arrest rather than issuing a citation for a minor traffic offense. Ms. Atwater was handcuffed and taken to jail even though she was charged with a seat belt violation punishable only with a small fine, and there was no legitimate law enforcement need to take her into custody (e.g., to confirm identification or prevent further dangerous driving). Seat belt violators are normally issued citations, 2 and it appears that the officer in this case made the arrest because he was angry at Ms. Atwater and wanted to teach her a lesson. 3

The decision in Atwater has been widely criticized, even by conservatives, 4 and with good reason. Indeed, the closer one looks at Justice Souter's majority opinion and the issues involved, the less sense it makes. The decision is "a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma." 5 The enigma is apparent from even a superficial recitation of the facts: 6 jailing a driver for a fine-only seat belt violation, with no need for custody whatsoever, and apparently in bad faith, is clearly unreasonable. The mystery deepens when one examines Justice Souter's reasons for rejecting Ms. Atwater's claim. Justice Souter seems to admit that, on the facts alleged by the Petitioner (and which the Court assumed to be true), her arrest was ...
 
 
If you are interested in obtaining a lexis.com® ID and Password, please contact us at 1-(800)-227-4908 or visit us at http://www.lexisnexis.com/.
Search Documents
 
eg., Environmental Insurance Coverage Under the Comprehensive General Liability Policy
 
 
 
 

Lexis® Web - The only search engine that delivers free web content specifically from legal sites validated by LexisNexis® attorney editors and includes tools for faster research and more relevant results.

 
LexisNexis Store
Research Now - Go to lexis.com
Connect the Dots - Free 1 hour webcast
Share. Network. Discover. - Go to LexisNexis Communities